Exodus 22 12
However, if the animal really was stolen from the neighbor, he must compensate the owner.
Compare with other 3 random translations
AMP Exodus 22:12But if it is actually stolen from him [when in his care], he shall make restitution to its owner.
CSB Exodus 22:12But if, in fact, the animal was stolen from his custody, he must make restitution to its owner.
LSV Exodus 22:12but if it is certainly stolen from him, he repays to its owner;